Interrogative AI Pedagogy in the Middle Years: A Conceptual Framework for Engagement, Writing Development, and Critical Digital Literacy in Urban Canadian Grades 5-8 Classrooms
Abstract
Generative artificial intelligence (AI) reached middle years classrooms before there was much scholarship on how to teach with it. Reviews of AI in elementary education tend to describe what the systems can do, and the Ontario Teachers' Federation (2026) notes that AI's effect on teaching and learning in Ontario K-12 education has not been systematically investigated. This conceptual article asks under what instructional conditions AI integration in urban Canadian Grades 5-8 classrooms is likely to produce learning, as opposed to its appearance, and which students are most affected when those conditions are missing. Using a theory synthesis approach, I bring together research on engagement, scaffolding, multilingual learners, technological pedagogical content knowledge, AI literacy, and digital equity. The result is interrogative AI pedagogy, a framework resting on four propositions: novelty is an entry point and not a design; AI scaffolds have to be designed to fade; justification, not the finished product, should be what teachers assess; and AI literacy must be taught and assessed explicitly. I also theorize a scaffold-substitution paradox. The multilingual learners and students with learning exceptionalities who stand to gain most from AI scaffolds are the same students most exposed to letting AI do their thinking for them. A sample instructional sequence shows how the framework might look in practice. The article closes with implications for assessment and teacher professional learning in urban boards, and with propositions that future empirical studies can test.
How to Cite This Article
Dr. Robin Persad (2026). Interrogative AI Pedagogy in the Middle Years: A Conceptual Framework for Engagement, Writing Development, and Critical Digital Literacy in Urban Canadian Grades 5-8 Classrooms . Global Multidisciplinary Perspectives Journal (GMPJ), 3(6), 17-26. DOI: https://doi.org/10.54660/GMPJ.2026.3.6.17-26